Choosing between fragrance samples & discovery sets is really a choice between focus and variety. One set is built around 24 perfume vials for scent testing, while the other combines perfume samples with makeup, skincare, and a tote. The right pick depends on whether you want a dedicated fragrance sampler or a more varied gift assortment.
Quick verdict
Choose 24 x Women's Designer Perfume Samples Set Lot if your priority is exploring perfumes in a consistent spray Eau de Parfum format. Its 24-vial lineup is more directly aligned with fragrance discovery and travel use. Choose Macys 27 Pcs Perfume Sample Gift Set if a mixed beauty gift feels more useful. The listed-price spread is $14.00, with the Macys set at the lower listed price.
At a glance
| Set | Listed price | Main format |
|---|---|---|
| 24 x Women's Designer Perfume Samples Set Lot | USD 36.99 | 24 perfume vials, spray formulation, sample size |
| Macys 27 Pcs Perfume Sample Gift Set | USD 22.99 | Perfume samples, beauty minis, and tote |
Where each set wins
- 24 x Women's Designer Perfume Samples Set Lot: Best suited to fragrance-first testing, with 24 authentic designer perfume vials and a scent range spanning notes such as citrus, floral, oud, rose, vanilla, and white musk.
- Macys 27 Pcs Perfume Sample Gift Set: Better for a mixed beauty presentation, since its contents include perfume samples, a tote, makeup, skincare, and cleanser items.
24 x Women's Designer Perfume Samples Set Lot
Choose the 24 x Women's Designer Perfume Samples Set Lot when the main goal is sampling fragrances rather than assembling a mixed beauty gift. The description specifies 24 authentic designer perfume vials, while the attributes identify a spray formulation and Eau de Parfum type. Its listed scent range includes bergamot, cherry, citrus, floral, jasmine, lavender, lime, oud, patchouli, rose, sandalwood, vanilla, white musk, and ylang ylang, giving fragrance shoppers several note directions to explore. The travel-friendly description also names purses, gym bags, and gift favors as suitable uses. The limitation is the USD 36.99 listed price, plus the fact that the vials are marked "Sample - Not for Sale," so the format is intended for discovery rather than full-size fragrance ownership.
Macys 27 Pcs Perfume Sample Gift Set
The Macys 27 Pcs Perfume Sample Gift Set makes more sense when perfume is only part of the intended gift. Alongside fragrance samples, it includes a tote and named beauty items such as Cartier Baiser Volé, Coach Love, Jo Malone London Wood Sage & Sea Salt, and Giorgio Armani Acqua Di Gio Profondo. The assortment also reaches makeup, skincare, facial care, and cleanser samples, creating a broader mini-beauty experience. That variety is also the main limitation: someone looking specifically for a fragrance-only sampler may find the contents less focused than the dedicated 24-vial lot. The title calls it a 27-piece set, while the listed size is Sample, so it is best approached as a collection of minis rather than a full-bottle fragrance purchase.
Final choice by use case
- For perfume-first exploration: Pick 24 x Women's Designer Perfume Samples Set Lot for its dedicated vial format, spray application, Eau de Parfum type, and broad listed scent range.
- For a mixed beauty gift: Pick Macys 27 Pcs Perfume Sample Gift Set for the combination of perfume samples, named beauty minis, and tote.
- For travel or a purse-sized fragrance rotation: The 24-vial lot has the clearer fit because its description specifically identifies travel, purses, and gym bags.
- For shoppers who want fragrance plus cosmetics and skincare: The Macys set is the more appropriate match because those categories appear among its named contents.
The decision is straightforward: the 24 x Women's Designer Perfume Samples Set Lot is the more focused fragrance discovery choice, while the Macys 27 Pcs Perfume Sample Gift Set suits a broader beauty-gifting purpose.
